Council planning record

Demolition of existing house and proposed 4no. three bed dwellings.

54 West Malvern Road Malvern WR14 4NA

RefusalReference: 16/01768/FULMalvern Hills District Council

Last published check: 3 Oct 2026, 09:02. Check the council record for more recent changes.

Application location

54 West Malvern Road Malvern WR14 4NA

This record has no verified map location.

Application summary

Status
Refusal
Application type
Full planning permission
Received
29 Nov 2016
Validated
21 Dec 2016
Determination deadline
Not published
Local authority
Malvern Hills District Council

Application overview

Demolition of existing house and proposed 4no. three bed dwellings.

Proposal details

Reference
16/01768/FUL
Ward
West Ward - Pre 01/05/23
Parish
Malvern CP
Agent
Mr Nick Carroll

Sign in to view all collected council fields and recorded changes.

Sign in to view collected details

Documents 103 of 103

DocumentPublishedAction
Application form01. Application Form21 Dec 2016View
Design and Access Statement02. Supporting Information21 Dec 2016View
Drainage strategy02. Supporting Information21 Dec 2016View
Bat survey report02. Supporting Information21 Dec 2016View
Rear View Photo02. Supporting Information10 Jan 2017View
Background Photo02. Supporting Information10 Jan 2017View
Level 3 - plans - 1325/0702. Supporting Information21 Dec 2016View
Site section - 1325-02d07. Revised Documents17 May 2017View
Roof level - 1325/08b04. Site / Location Plan21 Dec 2016View
Existing plans and elevations - 1325/0104. Site / Location Plan21 Dec 2016View
Level 1 - plan - 1325/05c07a. Revised Plans17 May 2017View
Level 2 - street level - 13250-6d07a. Revised Plans17 May 2017View
General side elevations - 1325-04d07a. Revised Plans17 May 2017View
Elevations - 1325-03d07a. Revised Plans17 May 2017View
Comment: Norman Bennett08. Response - Neighbour and Other5 Jan 2017View
Comment: Ron Henry08. Response - Neighbour and Other9 Jan 2017View
Comment: Mark Haslam08. Response - Neighbour and Other13 Jan 2017View
Comment: Padraig O'Dubhlaoidh08. Response - Neighbour and Other16 Jan 2017View
Comment: Helen Bowen08. Response - Neighbour and Other17 Jan 2017View
Comment: Steven Green08. Response - Neighbour and Other17 Jan 2017View
Comment:Helen Harmer08. Response - Neighbour and Other17 Jan 2017View
Comment: Karen Sammon08. Response - Neighbour and Other17 Jan 2017View
Comment: Mrs. Pat Moss08. Response - Neighbour and Other17 Jan 2017View
Comment: Sue Morris, Amy Clarke08. Response - Neighbour and Other17 Jan 2017View
Comment: Rachel Pritchard, Josie Thorne08. Response - Neighbour and Other17 Jan 2017View
Comment: Judy Gibson08. Response - Neighbour and Other17 Jan 2017View
Comment: Tim Bowen08. Response - Neighbour and Other18 Jan 2017View
Comment: Kevin Williams08. Response - Neighbour and Other18 Jan 2017View
Comment: Mr Gregory Cox08. Response - Neighbour and Other18 Jan 2017View
Comment: Ronald Henry08. Response - Neighbour and Other19 Jan 2017View
Comment: Claire Lucas08. Response - Neighbour and Other19 Jan 2017View
Comment: Mr And Mrs Roy08. Response - Neighbour and Other19 Jan 2017View
Comment: Keri WOOLLEY08. Response - Neighbour and Other19 Jan 2017View
Comment: Pauline and Chris Dumville08. Response - Neighbour and Other23 Jan 2017View
Heather Hunaban08. Response - Neighbour and Other7 Feb 2017View
Mark Dodge08. Response - Neighbour and Other7 Feb 2017View
Mrs. Julie Wood08. Response - Neighbour and Other7 Feb 2017View
Ian Sampson08. Response - Neighbour and Other7 Feb 2017View
James Kelly08. Response - Neighbour and Other7 Feb 2017View
Keri Wooley08. Response - Neighbour and Other7 Feb 2017View
Mr. R. Henry08. Response - Neighbour and Other7 Feb 2017View
Peter Scholefield08. Response - Neighbour and Other7 Feb 2017View
Comment: Worcestershire Regulatory Services09. Response - Statutory Consultee9 Jan 2017View
Comment: MHDC Housing09. Response - Statutory Consultee12 Jan 2017View
Civic Society09. Response - Statutory Consultee7 Feb 2017View
Malvern Hills AONB Partnership09. Response - Statutory Consultee7 Feb 2017View
Malvern Town Council09. Response - Statutory Consultee7 Feb 2017View
Highway Authority09. Response - Statutory Consultee15 Mar 2017View
Landscape Officer09. Response - Statutory Consultee12 May 2017View
South Worcestershire Land Drainage Partnership09. Response - Statutory Consultee15 May 2017View
Highway Authority09. Response - Statutory Consultee7 Jul 2017View
Delegated Report11. Decision Information7 Jul 2017View
Decision Notice12. Decision Notice14 Nov 2017View
Planning Appeal Decision12. Decision Notice26 Mar 2018View
Application Form13. DoC Application Form14 Aug 2019View
Elevations - Materials14. DoC Plans14 Aug 2019View
Landscape Block Plan14. DoC Plans14 Aug 2019View
Lower Level Groundworks14. DoC Plans14 Aug 2019View
Side Elevations - Materials14. DoC Plans14 Aug 2019View
Strategic Structural Section14. DoC Plans14 Aug 2019View
Bat Survey Report15. DoC Supporting Documents14 Aug 2019View
Construction Method Statement15. DoC Supporting Documents14 Aug 2019View
Ground Investigation Report15. DoC Supporting Documents14 Aug 2019View
Borehole 115. DoC Supporting Documents14 Aug 2019View
Borehole 215. DoC Supporting Documents14 Aug 2019View
Borehole 315. DoC Supporting Documents14 Aug 2019View
Borehole 415. DoC Supporting Documents14 Aug 2019View
Dynamic Probe 115. DoC Supporting Documents14 Aug 2019View
Dynamic Probe 215. DoC Supporting Documents14 Aug 2019View
Dynamic Probe 315. DoC Supporting Documents14 Aug 2019View
Northcott Victorian Mellow Brick15. DoC Supporting Documents14 Aug 2019View
Timber Cladding15. DoC Supporting Documents14 Aug 2019View
Energy Statement15. DoC Supporting Documents14 Aug 2019View
Water Efficiency Calculation15. DoC Supporting Documents14 Aug 2019View
Wheel Clean And Wash Provision.15. DoC Supporting Documents14 Aug 2019View
Discharge of Condition decision16. DoC Decision17 Jan 2020View
Appeal Application Form30. Appeal - Application Form25 Sept 2017View
Extension of Time Agreement from PINS for Questionnaire31. Appeal - Documents17 Nov 2017View
Appellant Grounds of Appeal31. Appeal - Documents17 Nov 2017View
LPA appeal form31. Appeal - Documents22 Nov 2017View
AONB Building Design Guide.pdf31. Appeal - Documents22 Nov 2017View
CIL Charging Schedule.pdf31. Appeal - Documents22 Nov 2017View
Consultee Comments.pdf31. Appeal - Documents22 Nov 2017View
Delegated Report.pdf31. Appeal - Documents22 Nov 2017View
Neighbour Comments.pdf31. Appeal - Documents22 Nov 2017View
SWDP - Relevant Policies.pdf31. Appeal - Documents22 Nov 2017View
Letter from PINS enclosing comments31. Appeal - Documents21 Dec 2017View
Worcestershire CC Highways - Appeal Statement.pdf31. Appeal - Documents21 Dec 2017View
3P - Worcestershire CC Highways - Appendix 1 - Highways comments.pdf31. Appeal - Documents21 Dec 2017View
3P - Worcestershire CC Highways - Appendix 2 - Highway Entents.pdf31. Appeal - Documents21 Dec 2017View
3rd Party Representation - MR & MRS ROY.pdf31. Appeal - Documents21 Dec 2017View
3rd Party Representation - SARAH O'HALLORAN.pdf31. Appeal - Documents21 Dec 2017View
Appellants Final Comments Appendics.pdf31. Appeal - Documents15 Jan 2018View
Email from PINS re Green Infrastructure31. Appeal - Documents24 Jan 2018View
Start Letter31. Appeal - Documents14 Nov 2017View
LPA PROOF OF EVIDENCE - 282092.pdf33. Appeal - Councils Case15 Dec 2017View
Statement of case 54 West Malvern Road.pdf33. Appeal - Councils Case15 Dec 2017View
Appendix 4 MHDC33. Appeal - Councils Case15 Dec 2017View
Appendix 5 MHDC33. Appeal - Councils Case15 Dec 2017View
Appendix 2 MHDC33. Appeal - Councils Case15 Dec 2017View
Appendix 3 MHDC33. Appeal - Councils Case15 Dec 2017View
Appendix 1 MHDC33. Appeal - Councils Case15 Dec 2017View
Final Decision.pdfAppeal - Decision26 Jan 2018View

Documents open on the council website. Browse council documents if a link has changed.

Application timeline

Council milestones and published deadlines. A deadline passing does not confirm a decision.

  1. Application Received Date

    Published milestoneCouncil source
  2. Application Valid Date

    Published milestoneCouncil source
  3. Consultation Start Date

    Published milestoneCouncil source
  4. Decision Date

    Published milestoneCouncil source

Decision & conditions

Refusal
Decision Notice Planning Appeal Decision Discharge of Condition decision Final Decision.pdf
Planning conditions

Conditions aren’t listed here. Read the council decision notice for the full decision and conditions.

Related records

Understand this planning record

All planning guides
  • Understanding planning · 13 min read

    Planning application documents: what to read first

    Understand planning application documents, officer reports and decision notices. Use a reading checklist, document table and worked example to inspect a case.

  • Understanding planning · 13 min read

    Planning application statuses explained

    Understand pending consideration, approved, refused and withdrawn planning applications. Compare status labels and find the documents explaining each outcome.

  • Understanding planning · 13 min read

    Planning permission drawings: how to read plans

    Read planning drawings, floor plans, elevations and sections. Use labelled diagrams, a drawing comparison table and revision checks to understand a proposal.