PlanningTrack
Get started

Council planning record

Erection of a new dwelling

Land at Spindleberry Tor, High Tor Lane, (Off Stocks Road) Alfrick, Worcestershire, WR6 5HB

RefusalReference: 16/01594/FULMalvern Hills District Council

Last published check: 3 Oct 2026, 16:20. Check the council record for more recent changes.

Application timeline

Council milestones and published deadlines. A deadline passing does not confirm a decision.

  1. Application Received Date

    Published milestoneCouncil source

  2. Application Valid Date

    Published milestoneCouncil source

  3. Consultation Start Date

    Published milestoneCouncil source

  4. Consultation End

    Past published deadline

    A published target or deadline. It does not confirm an outcome.

    Council source

  5. Advert Expiry

    Past published deadline

    A published target or deadline. It does not confirm an outcome.

    Council source

  6. Decision Date

    Published milestoneCouncil source

Application summary

Status
Refusal
Application type
Full planning permission
Received
31 Oct 2016
Validated
31 Oct 2016
Determination deadline
Not published
Local authority
Malvern Hills District Council

Application overview

Erection of a new dwelling

Proposal details

Reference
16/01594/FUL
Ward
Alfrick and Leigh Ward - Pre 01/05/23
Parish
Alfrick CP
Agent
Ms V Poole

Sign in to view all collected council fields and recorded changes.

Sign in to view collected details

Application location

Land at Spindleberry Tor, High Tor Lane, (Off Stocks Road) Alfrick, Worcestershire, WR6 5HB

This record has no verified map location.

Documents 130 of 130

DocumentPublishedAction
Application form Scale: Paper Size:01. Application Form31 Oct 2016View
Letter Scale: Paper Size:01. Application Form31 Oct 2016View
Comment: SWLD Partnership02. Supporting Information29 Nov 2016View
Comment: Ramblers Association02. Supporting Information1 Dec 2016View
Comment: WCC Public Rights of Way02. Supporting Information2 Dec 2016View
Comment: Highway Authority02. Supporting Information5 Dec 2016View
Comment: G P Brooke02. Supporting Information6 Dec 2016View
Comment: Mr & Mrs R Norris02. Supporting Information6 Dec 2016View
Comment: Natural England02. Supporting Information12 Dec 2016View
Comment: SW Land Drainage Partnership02. Supporting Information13 Dec 2016View
Comment: Worcestershire Wildlife Trust02. Supporting Information15 Dec 2016View
Comment: MHDC Landscape Officer02. Supporting Information20 Dec 2016View
Comment: Malvern Hills AONB Partnership02. Supporting Information23 Dec 2016View
Comment: Mr & Mrs Mead02. Supporting Information29 Dec 2016View
Comment: Mr & Mrs Tyler02. Supporting Information29 Dec 2016View
Comment: Geofffrey M. Brewin, Parish Council of Alfrick and Lulsley02. Supporting Information11 Jan 2017View
Comment: Natural England02. Supporting Information12 Jan 2017View
CIL exemption form part 102. Supporting Information2 Nov 2017View
EIA Screening Opinion PINS Nov 201702. Supporting Information9 Nov 2017View
Landscape plan - PW AP/PL 5 Scale: 1:500 Paper Size: A102. Supporting Information31 Oct 2016View
Landscape plan - PW AD/PL 4 Scale: 1:200 Paper Size: A102. Supporting Information31 Oct 2016View
Design and Access Statement Scale: Paper Size:02. Supporting Information31 Oct 2016View
Construction plan - CA103 Scale: 1:200 Paper Size: A302. Supporting Information31 Oct 2016View
Dark skies - CA102A Scale: 1:100 Paper Size: A302. Supporting Information31 Oct 2016View
Sustainability statement Scale: Paper Size:02. Supporting Information31 Oct 2016View
Planning statement Scale: Paper Size:02. Supporting Information31 Oct 2016View
Protected species survey report Scale: Paper Size:02. Supporting Information31 Oct 2016View
Landscape and visual impact assessment Scale: Paper Size:02. Supporting Information31 Oct 2016View
Phase 1 - Habitat and protected species risk assessment Scale: Paper Size:02. Supporting Information31 Oct 2016View
Client letter of representation Scale: Paper Size:02. Supporting Information31 Oct 2016View
Tree and large shrub survey Scale: Paper Size:02. Supporting Information31 Oct 2016View
Solar study - 106 Scale: 1:500 Paper Size: A102. Supporting Information31 Oct 2016View
3D's and perspectives - 105 Scale: - Paper Size: A102. Supporting Information31 Oct 2016View
Roof plan - 103 Scale: 1:200 Paper Size: A102. Supporting Information31 Oct 2016View
Tree protection plan - STA.115.T.3 Scale: Other Paper Size: A302. Supporting Information31 Oct 2016View
Tree works plan - STA.115.T.2 Scale: Other Paper Size: A302. Supporting Information31 Oct 2016View
Tree condition plan - STA.115.T.1 Scale: Other Paper Size: A302. Supporting Information31 Oct 2016View
Feasiblity Calculations Scale: - Paper Size: A402. Supporting Information5 Dec 2016View
Figure 2 - Protection Barrier Scale: - Paper Size: A402. Supporting Information15 Dec 2016View
Table 2 - Calculation of Root Protection Area Scale: Other Paper Size: A302. Supporting Information15 Dec 2016View
Table 1 - Tree Quality Assessment Scale: - Paper Size: A402. Supporting Information15 Dec 2016View
Tree Survey Scale: - Paper Size: A402. Supporting Information15 Dec 2016View
Specification for Root Protection Area Scale: - Paper Size: A402. Supporting Information15 Dec 2016View
Ground Protection Mats Scale: - Paper Size: A402. Supporting Information15 Dec 2016View
Ground Guards Protection Quote Scale: - Paper Size: A402. Supporting Information15 Dec 2016View
NJUG Tree Guidelines Scale: - Paper Size: A402. Supporting Information15 Dec 2016View
Figure 4 Trenching Scale: - Paper Size: A402. Supporting Information15 Dec 2016View
Figure 3 Scaffolding within Root Protection Area Scale: - Paper Size: A402. Supporting Information15 Dec 2016View
Heras Fence Details Scale: - Paper Size: A402. Supporting Information15 Dec 2016View
Elevations - 104 Scale: 1:100 Paper Size: A104. Site / Location Plan31 Oct 2016View
Proposed floor plans - 102 Scale: 1:100 Paper Size: A104. Site / Location Plan31 Oct 2016View
Proposed site and location plan - 101 Scale: Other Paper Size: A104. Site / Location Plan31 Oct 2016View
Existing site and location plan - 001 Scale: Other Paper Size: A104. Site / Location Plan31 Oct 2016View
AMENDED Foul and Storm Drainage Feasiblity Layout 2124/2016/001 Rev C rec'd 5.12.16 Scale: Other Paper Size: A104. Site / Location Plan5 Dec 2016View
Officer Report12. Decision Notice12 Jan 2017View
Decision Notice12. Decision Notice12 Jan 2017View
Appeal Form30. Appeal - Application Form11 Jul 2017View
Planning Appeal Statement31. Appeal - Documents11 Jul 2017View
Hearing Start Letter31. Appeal - Documents26 Oct 2017View
Appendices to Appellant Statement Part 231. Appeal - Documents26 Oct 2017View
List of Appendices to Statement of Case31. Appeal - Documents26 Oct 2017View
Appendix 1 - Decision Notice31. Appeal - Documents26 Oct 2017View
Appendix 2 - Delegated Officer Report31. Appeal - Documents26 Oct 2017View
Appendix 3 - Completed Application Form31. Appeal - Documents26 Oct 2017View
Appendix 4 - Site and Location Plan (existing)31. Appeal - Documents26 Oct 2017View
Appendix 5 - Site and Location Plan (proposed)31. Appeal - Documents26 Oct 2017View
Appendix 6 - Floor Plans31. Appeal - Documents26 Oct 2017View
Appendix 7 - Roof Plan31. Appeal - Documents26 Oct 2017View
Appendix 8 - Elevation Plan31. Appeal - Documents26 Oct 2017View
Appendix 9 - 3D Visuals and Perspectives31. Appeal - Documents26 Oct 2017View
Appendix 10 - Solar Study Plan31. Appeal - Documents26 Oct 2017View
Appendix 11 - Lighting Plan31. Appeal - Documents26 Oct 2017View
Appendix 12 - Construction Plan31. Appeal - Documents26 Oct 2017View
Appendix 13 - Design and Access Statement31. Appeal - Documents26 Oct 2017View
Appendix 14 - Sustainability Statement31. Appeal - Documents26 Oct 2017View
Appendix 15 - Planting Plan (part 1)31. Appeal - Documents26 Oct 2017View
Appendix 16 - Planting Plan (part 2)31. Appeal - Documents26 Oct 2017View
Appendix 17 - Tree Shrubbery Survey31. Appeal - Documents26 Oct 2017View
Appendix 18 - Tree Condition Plan31. Appeal - Documents26 Oct 2017View
Appendix 19 - Tree Works Plan31. Appeal - Documents26 Oct 2017View
Appendix 20 - Tree Protection Plan31. Appeal - Documents26 Oct 2017View
Appendix 21 - Specification for porous paving in RPAs31. Appeal - Documents26 Oct 2017View
Appendix 22 - Trenching with Root Protection Area31. Appeal - Documents26 Oct 2017View
Appendix 23 - Scaffolding within Root Protection Area31. Appeal - Documents26 Oct 2017View
Appendix 24 - Root Protection Area calculation formula31. Appeal - Documents26 Oct 2017View
Appendix 25 - Guidelines for works within proximity to trees31. Appeal - Documents26 Oct 2017View
Appendix 26 - Protective barrier for trees31. Appeal - Documents26 Oct 2017View
Appendix 27 - Cascade chart for tree assessment31. Appeal - Documents26 Oct 2017View
Appendix 28 - Ground Guards Specification31. Appeal - Documents26 Oct 2017View
Appendix 29 - Ground Protection Matting Specification31. Appeal - Documents26 Oct 2017View
Appendix 30 - Phase 1 Habitat Survey31. Appeal - Documents26 Oct 2017View
Appendix 31 - Bat and Great Crested Newts Study31. Appeal - Documents26 Oct 2017View
Appendix 32 - Landscape and Visual Impact Assessment31. Appeal - Documents26 Oct 2017View
Appendix 33 - Applicant Letter31. Appeal - Documents26 Oct 2017View
Appendix 34 - Planning Statement31. Appeal - Documents26 Oct 2017View
Appendix 35 - Foul and Storm Feasiblity Layout31. Appeal - Documents26 Oct 2017View
Appendix 36 - Drainage Calculations31. Appeal - Documents26 Oct 2017View
Appendix 37a - MADE Executive Summary Report31. Appeal - Documents26 Oct 2017View
Appendix 37b - Plans for MADE31. Appeal - Documents26 Oct 2017View
Appendix 38 - MADE Correspondence31. Appeal - Documents26 Oct 2017View
Appendix 39 - SWDP Policies31. Appeal - Documents26 Oct 2017View
Appendix 40 - Little Fosters Appeal Decision31. Appeal - Documents26 Oct 2017View
Appendix 41 - Woldsend Appeal Decision31. Appeal - Documents26 Oct 2017View
Appendix 42a - Appeal Statement Sharpe Ecology31. Appeal - Documents26 Oct 2017View
Appendix 42b - Appendix 1 to Sharpe Ecology31. Appeal - Documents26 Oct 2017View
LPA Questionnaire31. Appeal - Documents31 Oct 2017View
Draft statement of common ground from appellant31. Appeal - Documents7 Nov 2017View
CIL form part 131. Appeal - Documents7 Nov 2017View
Environmental Impact Assessment31. Appeal - Documents9 Nov 2017View
Covering Letter - Environmental Impact Assessment31. Appeal - Documents9 Nov 2017View
Statement of Common Ground31. Appeal - Documents20 Nov 2017View
letter re hearing statement31. Appeal - Documents23 Nov 2017View
PINS confirmation of venue for hearing31. Appeal - Documents13 Dec 2017View
SSSI map31. Appeal - Documents24 Jan 2018View
Ancient woodland map31. Appeal - Documents24 Jan 2018View
Email response to PINS query33. Appeal - Councils Case23 Nov 2017View
Appendix 11 - LPA Suggested Conditions.pdf33. Appeal - Councils Case23 Nov 2017View
Appeal Statement.pdf33. Appeal - Councils Case23 Nov 2017View
Appendix 1 - Public footpaths map.pdf33. Appeal - Councils Case23 Nov 2017View
Appendix 2 - Landscape Character Assessment Supplementary Guidance.pdf33. Appeal - Councils Case23 Nov 2017View
Appendix 3 - Environmental constraints plans.pdf33. Appeal - Councils Case23 Nov 2017View
Appendix 4 - AONB Management Plan 2014-19.pdf33. Appeal - Councils Case23 Nov 2017View
Appendix 5 - AONB Building Design Guide.pdf33. Appeal - Councils Case23 Nov 2017View
Appendix 6 - AONB Colour Guidance.pdf33. Appeal - Councils Case23 Nov 2017View
Appendix 7 - Appeal decision in Buckinghamshire.pdf33. Appeal - Councils Case23 Nov 2017View
Appendix 8 - Historic maps.pdf33. Appeal - Councils Case23 Nov 2017View
Appendix 9 - Appeal decision in Oxfordshire.pdf33. Appeal - Councils Case23 Nov 2017View
Appendix 10 - Leigh Brook Valley SSSI designation.pdf33. Appeal - Councils Case23 Nov 2017View
LPA STATEMENT OF CASE - 275234.pdf33. Appeal - Councils Case24 Nov 2017View
Appeal DecisionAppeal - Decision29 Jan 2018View

Documents open on the council website. Browse council documents if a link has changed.

Decision & conditions

Refusal
Decision Notice Appendix 1 - Decision Notice Appendix 40 - Little Fosters Appeal Decision Appendix 41 - Woldsend Appeal Decision Appendix 7 - Appeal decision in Buckinghamshire.pdf Appendix 9 - Appeal decision in Oxfordshire.pdf Appeal Decision
Planning conditions

Conditions aren’t listed here. Read the council decision notice for the full decision and conditions.

Related records
  • appeal · Linked by the council

Understand this planning record

All planning guides

  • Understanding planning · 13 min read

    Planning application documents: what to read first

    Understand planning application documents, officer reports and decision notices. Use a reading checklist, document table and worked example to inspect a case.

    UK research
    Published Updated

  • Understanding planning · 13 min read

    Planning application statuses explained

    Understand pending consideration, approved, refused and withdrawn planning applications. Compare status labels and find the documents explaining each outcome.

    UK research
    Published Updated

  • Understanding planning · 13 min read

    Planning permission drawings: how to read plans

    Read planning drawings, floor plans, elevations and sections. Use labelled diagrams, a drawing comparison table and revision checks to understand a proposal.

    UK research
    Published Updated